top of page
Business office

GUIDE · UPWORK VS A STAFFING COMPANY

Upwork or a staffing company:
which is right for you?

Freelancer platforms suit short projects. Ongoing roles need someone who works only for you. This guide compares the costs, Fair Work risk, data security and reliability of each, so you can choose the right model for the work.

3% to 10%

Upwork's marketplace fee on every payment

US dollars

how Upwork bills Australian clients

26 Aug 2024

Fair Work's "real substance" test for contractors began

From $1,950

+ GST a month, in AUD, with TalentBridge

HOW EACH MODEL WORKS

Same work,
different employer.

The difference is who does the employer's job: finding the person, engaging them, paying them and providing the equipment.

Orange clock

Freelancer platform

You post a job, choose from proposals and agree a rate. The freelancer uses their own computer, sets their own hours and can work for other clients.

Orange pencil writing

The grey zone

A freelancer who works full-time, set hours, under your direction and on your systems can be treated as your employee, whatever the contract says.

Orange person with a plus sign

Offshore staffing company

The company shortlists and you choose. Your team member works only for you, full-time, in your hours, while the company handles contracts, payroll, leave, equipment and security.

sine-wave.png

WHAT YOU SEE

The hourly rate

+

01

Marketplace fee

+

02

Contract fee

+

03

Exchange rate

+

04

Your time

=

WHAT YOU PAY

The real cost

%

01

Marketplace fee

On every payment

TYPICAL COST

3% or 5% on a basic account, or 8% to 10% on Business Plus.

WHY IT MATTERS

It applies for as long as the freelancer works for you.

02

Contract fee

Each new contract

TYPICAL COST

A one-off US$0.99 to US$14.99 per contract.

WHY IT MATTERS

Small, but it comes round again each time you rehire or replace someone.

$

03

Exchange rate

Billed in US dollars

TYPICAL COST

Your cost moves with the Australian dollar.

WHY IT MATTERS

A monthly budget in AUD becomes harder to hold.

04

Your time

Hiring and managing

TYPICAL COST

Posting, shortlisting, interviewing, and checking hours and quality.

WHY IT MATTERS

If the freelancer leaves, you start again from the beginning.

WHAT EACH REALLY COSTS

The hourly rate
isn't the whole cost.

On Upwork, these costs sit on top of the freelancer's rate, and most of them don't show until the work has started.

WITH TALENTBRIDGE

One monthly fee,
in Australian dollars.

For a full-time, experienced team member in the Philippines. One invoice covers their pay and everything around it.

ADMIN ASSISTANT

$1,950

+ GST a month

BOOKKEEPER

$2,650

+ GST a month

ACCOUNTANT

$3,150

+ GST a month

Starting prices. Your quote depends on the role and experience.

 

● No placement fee    ● No currency risk    ● 30 days' notice, no lock-in

WHAT'S INCLUDED

Everything an employer would do, done for you

Recruitment icon

Recruitment

Filled in 1 to 6 weeks. You interview and choose.

Pay and leave icon

Pay and leave

Salary, leave and public holidays.

HR and payroll icon

HR and payroll

Contracts, payroll and daily timesheets.

Police check icon

Police check

Every team member, before day one.

Managed laptop icon

Managed laptop

ISO 27001 certified security, set up and monitored.

Replacements icon

Replacements

If someone leaves or isn't the right fit, we find a replacement.

One invoice a month, in AUD. Nothing else to pay on top.

security.jpg
Orange tick within a circle

Pascua v Doessel Group (2024)

A Philippines-based paralegal on an "Independent Contractor's Agreement" was found to be the law firm's employee. She won her unfair dismissal claim and was awarded $10,800.

Orange tick within a circle

What the test looks at

Since 26 August 2024, the Fair Work Act looks at the real substance, practical reality and true nature of the relationship, not the contract's label.

Orange tick within a circle

What it can cost

Backpay, leave entitlements, unfair dismissal claims and sham contracting penalties.

When a freelancer
becomes an employee.

THE LEGAL RISK

Warning signs: full-time or fixed hours set by you, daily direction from your team, your company email or systems, working only for you, and being paid for time rather than results.
 
This guide is general information, not legal advice. Read more: are my offshore staff employees?
sine-wave.png

SIDE BY SIDE

Freelancer platform vs staffing company.

Eight things that change between the two models.

Freelancer platform

e.g. Upwork · best for short, defined projects

TalentBridge

Best for ongoing, full-time roles

Finding the person

✕  You, from proposals

Orange tick within a circle

We shortlist, you interview and choose

Who engages them

✕  You, as a contractor, with the Fair Work risk

Orange tick within a circle

TalentBridge

Hours

✕  Set by the freelancer

Orange tick within a circle

Full-time, in your business hours

Works only for you

✕  Not usually

Orange tick within a circle

Yes, every day

Pricing

✕  Hourly in US$, plus platform fees

Orange tick within a circle

One monthly fee in AUD, from $1,950 + GST

Payroll, leave and HR

✕  Not covered

Orange tick within a circle

Handled for you

Equipment and security

✕  Their own computer

Orange tick within a circle

Managed laptop, ISO 27001 certified

If they leave

✕  You start again

Orange tick within a circle

We find a replacement

✓ handled for you    ✕ left with you or a risk to manage

WHICH TO CHOOSE

Choose by the work, not the rate.

A freelancer platform is the right tool for a project with an end. A staffing company is built for a role you'll need every day.
 
Not sure which fits? Book a free call.
People having a discussion
Orange tick in a circle

Use a freelancer for

Projects with a clear end: a design, a website change or a one-off report, with no sensitive client data.

Orange tick in a circle

Use a staffing company for

Ongoing, full-time roles such as bookkeeping, accounts, property administration or general admin, working your hours.

Orange tick in a circle

Client data

Freelancers use their own computers. TalentBridge team members use managed laptops, and the optional Secure Desktop keeps files in Sydney.

Orange tick in a circle

Already have a freelancer?

A team transition moves them to TalentBridge so they're engaged properly. Transition your team

looking-for-information.jpg

Working with a freelancer
full-time already?

Book a free call. We'll look at how they're engaged today and whether a team transition makes sense.

FAQ

Upwork vs a staffing company:
common questions.

Is Upwork cheaper than an offshore staffing company?

For a short project, often yes. For a full-time role, compare the hourly rate × hours, plus Upwork's fees, the exchange rate, equipment and your own time, against one monthly fee that includes all of those.

What fees does Upwork charge clients?

A marketplace fee of 3% or 5% on a basic account (8% to 10% on Business Plus), plus a one-off contract initiation fee of US$0.99 to US$14.99. Payments are in US dollars.

Can an overseas freelancer be my employee under Australian law?

They can. The Fair Work Commission found a Philippines-based worker on a contractor agreement was an employee of an Australian law firm in Pascua v Doessel Group (2024). What matters is how the relationship works in practice.

How do I know if my freelancer looks like an employee?

Warning signs include full-time or fixed hours, daily direction from your team, your company email or systems, and working only for you.

Who employs my team member with an offshore staffing company?

With TalentBridge, your team member is legally engaged by TalentBridge, not by your business. They work only for you and take direction from your team.

Can I move an existing freelancer to TalentBridge?

Yes. A team transition moves your existing offshore worker across so they're engaged properly, with payroll, leave and security handled.

Is my data safer with a staffing company?

It can be. TalentBridge team members work on managed laptops under ISO 27001 certified security, and the optional Secure Desktop keeps client files in Sydney.

How long does it take to hire through TalentBridge?

Most roles are filled in 1 to 6 weeks, and you interview and choose the person.

Sources

Upwork client fees: marketplace fee and contract initiation fee. Upwork, 2026; Upwork Help

Definition of employment from 26 August 2024. Fair Work Ombudsman

Pascua v Doessel Group [2024] FWC 2669; appeal dismissed [2025] FWCFB 43. HR Legal; Dynamic Business

Sending personal information overseas (APP 8). OAIC

This guide is general information, not financial, tax or legal advice. Figures checked November 2026.

Office Hallway Discussion

Get in contact

Sign up for all the latest tips, tricks, and trends

Thank you for subscribing to our newsletter.

Level 35, 100 Barangaroo Avenue

Barangaroo NSW 2000

To get started, contact us on:

​

​1800 418 625

Items on a desk

© 2026 by TalentBridge Pty Ltd.

bottom of page